Advertiser Disclosure
Lifestyle Essentials

Best Men’s Underwear Reviewed:
MeUndies vs. SAXX vs. Tommy John

We reviewed MeUndies, SAXX, and Tommy John to help you pick the best underwear. Say goodbye to your worn-out undies and upgrade to the best men's underwear available.

MeUndies vs SAXX vs Tommy John Underwear - Cover Image

Most guys are low maintenance. They work hard, play hard, and avoid sweating the small stuff. Unfortunately, that also means the underwear drawer sometimes gets a little worn out and neglected. If that is the case for you or the man in your life, it’s time to invest in some quality underwear. You will thank us later.

Consider which piece of clothing you wear most often and most closely to your sacred parts. It’s your undies, so if you have opted for box-store 5-packs in the past, there will be no turning back once you have upgraded to one of these superior underwear brands.

MeUndies vs. SAXX vs. Tommy John - Men’s Underwear Compared

If you like the convenience of buying your underwear from the same place you buy your groceries, then, by all means, go for it. That said, if there is one thing you should consider spending a few extra dollars on for quality and comfort, it’s your underwear. But which brand should you choose?

There are a growing number of brands on the market including B3NTH, Mack Weldon, Stance, and even Lululemon.

Based on our research, three brands stand above the rest, and that is why we compared MeUndiesMeUndies vs. SAXXSAXX vs. Tommy JohnTommy John to find the perfect men’s underwear. 😎

Not convinced? Keep reading and check out the reviews below. To quote an anonymous reviewer, “Life is too short to wear uncomfortable underwear.” We agree.

MeUndies vs. SAXX vs. Tommy John Underwear
Comparison Table
Best Men's Underwear ReviewedMeUndies LogoSAXX LogoTommy Johns Logo
PriceaddMeUndies💰💰SAXX💰💰💰Tommy Johns💰💰💰
Biggest Selling PointaddMeUndiesIncredibly SoftSAXXProprietary SupportTommy JohnsUnobtrusively Thin
Sport OptionaddMeUndiesSAXXTommy Johns
Subscription OptionaddMeUndiesSAXXTommy Johns
Bulk Pack DiscountsaddMeUndiesSAXXTommy Johns
ShippingaddMeUndiesFree US Shipping and ReturnsSAXXFree on orders over $50Tommy JohnsFree Shipping & Returns
WebsiteaddMeUndiesSAXXTommy Johns

What is the best men’s underwear?

MeUndies, SAXX, and Tommy John all offer men’s underwear that is extremely comfortable and stand above the rest of the competition. Each brand has unique features which might appeal to you, but know this: This isn’t your granddaddy’s underwear. Times change, and so should the inventory in your underwear drawer. When comparing MeUndies vs. SAXX vs. Tommy John it is hard to go wrong, but this is what we love about each brand:

  • MeUndiesMeUndies Underwear - Best Overall Value
  • SAXXSAXX Men’s Underwear - Most Supportive Design
  • Tommy JohnTommy John Men’s Underwear - Most Breathable Fabric

MeUndies vs. Tommy John vs. SAXX Article Review Image

What Should You Consider When Buying New Underwear?

If you bought cheap box-store underwear in the past, it might be hard to know where to start when looking to upgrade to the big leagues. After hours and hours of research and sampling, we think there are three things you need to consider.

  • Is the underwear comfortable?
  • Is the underwear durable?
  • Is the underwear functional?

Based on these criteria, MeUndies, SAXX, and Tommy John are our favorite underwear brands. All three brands make underwear that check the boxes. They are comfortable, durable, and functional—nothing less than you need, and nothing more than you need either. There is no need for extra bells and whistles here. Men want underwear that gets the job done comfortably.

It’s time to look and feel both young and inspired, like a million bucks. It’s time to upgrade from your granddaddy’s underwear, and we will help you make a confident decision you will appreciate for years to come.

MeUndies Men’s Underwear Review: Soft, Comfortable, and Convenient

MeUndies’ best quality is that they are incredibly soft and comfortable. They are legitimately so comfortable that you may not be willing to wear any other underwear once you try them on. Beyond comfort, MeUndies stands out for its subscription service. For a discounted price, you can have a fresh pair of underwear delivered to your door every month.

MeUndiesMeUndies organizes its colorways into three categories, and if you choose to set up a subscription, you will pick the type that best fits your personality. Classic colorways include more conservative mainstays (i.e., black, navy, and grey). Bold colorways include a brighter punch without getting too crazy (i.e., red, purple, and bright blues). Adventurous colorways include wild prints (i.e., orcas, bicycles, and plaid designs).

Not sure about an underwear subscription? Admittedly, it seemed strange to us until we tried it, but now we can’t imagine buying underwear any other way. It’s a deceptively convenient subscription. I found that, subconsciously, buying new underwear was a hassle, and I often just didn’t do it. But now my underwear drawer is fresh, and I actually look forward to sliding on a pair of MeUndies after I hop out of the shower because they are so perfectly soft and supportive in all the right ways.

And if you think I am exaggerating, I’m not. For real. Putting on a fresh pair of MeUndies is something I look forward to enjoying. Imagine finding pleasure in something so simple.

Like any good underwear brand, various cuts are available, so whether you prefer trunks, briefs, or boxer briefs, you will be pleased. While that’s not surprising, what might be surprising is that MeUndies offers lounge pants and other apparel made from the same buttery soft blend from which their underwear is made. Once you feel how soft the underwear is, you will be asking how you can wear it more, and MeUndies has you covered.

One final MeUndiesMeUndies feature which might be of interest is they offer matching partner underwear. MeUndies makes it easy to purchase matching underwear for the special person in your life if that is something they might get a kick out of. And really, what’s more personal than matching intimates? Regardless of whether you need partner-matching underwear, you will be glad you bought some new MeUndies.

More MeUndies Customer Reviews

Are you curious about what other customers think? Let’s check out what other buyers are saying:

Review from Ian: Quality is great, and they last. I have been a member for over two years now, and the quality has always remained the same. I am happy to start receiving my monthly packages again after some time of not receiving MeUndiesMeUndies. I really don’t want any other underwear.

Review from Eshli: I bought this intending to give it to my man friend for his birthday, long story short I have been wearing them instead and they are the most comfortable underwear.

Review from Trevor: My wife and I have birthdays a few days apart, so I purchased these as a gift for the both of us, and it is honestly the most comfortable pair of underwear that I have ever owned. We both love them!

Review from Josh: I have been a long-time member and absolutely love their products. Everything fits wonderfully, and I even got my girlfriend and her kids wearing them, and they love it, too. We are a regular, meundies family!

MeUndies vs. SAXX vs. Tommy John Review Image

MeUndies Men’s Underwear Review - The Verdict

When I first tried on a pair of MeUndies, I only regretted not finding them sooner. I honestly didn’t know how uncomfortable my old underwear was until I experienced MeUndies-level comfort. It’s not just the indescribably soft touch of the underwear, but also the waistband design.

The waistband isn’t very tall, maybe about an inch tall, which prevents the waistband from folding over and bunching up. We’ve seen claims from competitor brands about taller waistbands “laying flat” and maximizing comfort, but we have found the exact opposite to be true. The tall waistbands from competitors are the ones that fold over and bunch up rather than lying flat. MeUndies’MeUndies’ waistband actually lays flat, preventing annoying bunching, and maximizing comfort.


SUMMARYthumb_up PROS
thumb_down CONS
  • checkInsanely soft
  • closeNot great for playing sports
  • checkMost comfortable waistband
  • checkSubscription available
  • checkMatching his/her sets
  • checkGood selection of colors and designs
  • checkFun Branding
  • checkGreat Value

MeUndies vs. Tommy John vs. SAXX Review Image

SAXX Men’s Underwear Review: Versatile Support

As you might have guessed from the name, SAXX’s most prominent selling feature is their proprietary… well, a sack for your jewels. They call it the BallPark Pouch, and this unique design keeps you more supported than any other brand out there. With the BallPark Pouch design, your boys will stay in place.

While support is the most apparent benefit of SAXX’s unique design, it isn’t the only benefit. Have you ever dealt with sticking or uncomfortable friction? The mesh-panel pouch design is breathable, but it also keeps permanent separation where it is needed most. With SAXX’s unique pouch design, everything stays right where you want it: cool, calm, and collected.

We love that SAXXSAXX looks for the uncomfortable annoyances that are part of everyday life and then develops break-through technologies to make life a little better for us guys. Sometimes it is small improvements that make a big difference. It’s this attention to every little detail and potential discomfort that will make you love your SAXX.

SAXX has integrated their very special pouch into various products, so whether you are looking for everyday underwear or athletic underwear, there will be an option that works for you. In fact, for those looking for extreme convenience, SAXX also offers a line of two-in-one shorts where their BallPark Pouch is built right into shorts and sleepwear. Stay chafe-free at the beach or just around town. Nice.

Stylistically, SAXXSAXX leans toward eclectic and bright designs, but they have more conservative options too if that is what you prefer. Like MeUndies above and Tommy John below, SAXX comes in a variety of cuts, so you can find a supportive pair that is just right for you.

More SAXX Customer Reviews

Are you curious about what other customers think? Let’s check out what other buyers are saying:

Review from Terry: Never even thought about “special pants” before, but I must say I am sold on these for walking, very comfortable and highly recommended despite the cost.

Review from Peek: Top marks, ideal for walking thanks to the ventilated mesh and the ‘ballpark’ which keeps the crown jewels from rubbing on my pants, even after a long day’s trog. Worth the price!

Anonymous Review: I resisted for a while due to the relative cost of SAXXSAXX compared to underwear purchased in bulk from most big-box retailers. Boy, what a stupid decision! The most comfortable underwear out there, period! Worth every penny! I have since purchased another dozen pairs and don’t wear anything else! Life is too short to wear uncomfortable underwear.

Review from George: I hadn’t quite anticipated the supportive sensation of the Ballpark Pouch—less than a jock but enough to keep things managed. I was also surprised at how the design automatically guided things to their proper places without manual adjustment. Feels great!

SAXX vs. MeUndies vs. Tommy John Review Image

SAXX Underwear Review - The Verdict

Some people might not like the feel of being all wrapped up, but you won’t know until you try! For the most part, everything slides right into place, and most people love the supportive feeling. The SAXXSAXX pouch is designed with breathable mesh too, so while SAXX will keep you in place, they won’t unnecessarily heat everything up to get the job done.

SUMMARYthumb_up PROS
thumb_down CONS
  • checkVery supportive
  • closeUnique fit might not be for everyone
  • checkBreathable
  • closeNo subscription option
  • checkFrictionless
  • checkInnovative design
  • checkAthletic options available

SAXX vs. Tommy John vs. MeUndies Review Image

Tommy John Men’s Underwear Review: Luxuriously Thin and Smooth

Tommy John has built out their portfolio to have an option for just about everything you need, but one of their centerpieces is the Second Skin line of underwear. The Second Skin line is soft and stretchy but also very thin. If you are looking to avoid added bulk in your pants, this might be the brand for you.

These Second Skin undies are so thin and smooth you might forget you are wearing them at all. Tommy John has improved the Second Skin line too, so not only are they luxuriously soft, but they are twice as durable as previous versions. And while Tommy JohnTommy John doesn’t ride with the full wrap-around sack, they do feature a well-fitting contour pouch to keep you secure.

If you’re not sure about the Second Skin line, Tommy John also has a Cool Cotton line, which will help you beat the heat during the summer, and a SleekHeat line you can wear a base layer during the colder months.

If SAXX and their pouch aren’t for you, the one place where Tommy John stands above MeUndies is that they have underwear explicitly designed for athletic activities. Tommy John’s athletic underwear is designed for ultimate mobility, with enhanced breathability and durability compared to Tommy John’s other underwear lines. And if you need a place to put a key when you are out for a run, they have a built-in pocket as an optional feature.

And if that isn’t enough to pique your interest in Tommy John, check out the Go Anywhere line that not only includes underwear but everyday clothing such as polos and pants. The entire Go Anywhere lineup is made from Tommy John’s advanced fabric with quick-drying and multidirectional stretch features.

The bottom line is Tommy JohnTommy John makes quality underwear for any occasion. Since they have expanded their portfolio, you can update other parts of your wardrobe while replenishing your underwear drawer.

More Tommy John Customer Reviews

Are you curious about what other customers think? Let’s check out what other buyers are saying:

Review from Santiago: These Boxer Briefs are outstanding, well made, and very comfortable. I’m looking forward to getting in my next order.

Review from Ed: Best underwear ever took me almost 62 years to find them!

Review from Mike: Most comfortable underwear I have ever worn. I bought three pairs to try them out, and as soon as I put them on, I went back on the website and bought two more. Tommy John will be the only underwear I buy from now on.

Review from Brandon: These are by far the most comfortable underwear I’ve ever worn, and they are exactly what I wanted/needed while working outside all day.

Review from Bruce: I was never one to worry about underwear. Until I bought my first pair of Tommy John’s, now I’m hooked! These are perfect to work out in. They’re comfortable, durable, and feel great!

Tommy John vs. MeUndies vs. SAXX Review Image

Tommy John Underwear Review - The Verdict

Some wearers find Tommy John underwear runs a little tight, so we recommend you review their sizing guides and on-site customer reviews closely. Our favorite all-around underwear is from MeUndies, and if you are looking for superior support, we recommend SAXX. Tommy JohnTommy John is our recommendation if you are looking for athletic underwear, but aren’t sure about SAXX’s special pouch.

SUMMARYthumb_up PROS
thumb_down CONS
  • checkLuxuriously thin
  • closeFit not as comfortable as other brands
  • checkVersatile
  • closeNo subscription option
  • checkFrictionless

Tommy John vs. SAXX vs. MeUndies Review Image

What Are The Other Men’s Underwear Options?

We think you will find exactly what you need if you narrow down your choice to MeUndies, SAXX, and Tommy John, but there are quite a few brands out there these days. If you aren’t sold on our top three choices, these would be the next brands we would check out:

When it comes down to it, all three brands offer unique underwear features, but in our review, MeUndiesMeUndies stands above the rest. The fabric is smooth and comfortable, and the underwear doesn’t bunch up. The waistband is the perfect width, so it doesn’t fold over or scrunch up either.

We love the color palette choices, ranging from classic to adventurous because there is something for everyone’s personality. Most of all, we love the subscription option. Most men don’t spend a ton of time thinking about underwear, so setting up a subscription is an incredibly low-maintenance way to keep your underwear drawer fresh.

In fact, while you are at it, you might love MeUndiesMeUndies so much that you decide to add a subscription for undershirts and socks too. The subscription service is easy to use, and in fact, I personally have used the subscription service for years. The MeUndies subscription service eliminates the need for me to ever think about my underwear drawer, which is a win in my book.

Combine the ease of the subscription service with the incredibly soft and well-fitting underwear, and you find yourself with an easy decision. If your underwear drawer needs a little attention, we highly recommend stocking up on MeUndies today.

MeUndies vs. SAXX vs. Tommy John Article Review Image

Subscribe to Moonlight Reviews

Get the latest posts delivered right to your inbox