Advertiser DisclosureHome Comforts

Don't Lose Sleep.
Top 3 Cotton-Alternative Sheets:
Buffy vs. Cozy Earth
vs. Sheets & Giggles

We reviewed Buffy, Cozy Earth, and Sheets & Giggles to highlight the best cotton-alternative, hypoallergenic sheets on the market. Don't compromise comfort while sleeping.

Buffy vs Cozy Earth vs Sheets & Giggles - Cover Image

The more things change, the more they stay the same. Such is the case with your sheets. The world around us is changing at break-neck speed, but chances are, you have been sleeping in the same cotton-style sheets for decades. Today is the day for a change.

Traditional cotton sheets are naturally more prone to trap moisture than their eucalyptus or bamboo counterparts. This is a big deal because the moisture-wicking properties natural to eucalyptus and bamboo sheets fight bacterial growth and other indoor allergens. The tight weave found in hypoallergenic sheets also makes dust mites less likely.

So, when you buy these sheets, you can proudly know you made a decision that is both unique and responsible. Even better, you will be diving into a new pair of sheets that are more comfortable and breathable than your old cotton sheets.

Buffy vs. Cozy Earth vs. Sheets & Giggles Comparison

Buffy, Cozy Earth, and Sheets & Giggles are all industry changers in their own way. So which brand should you choose? We will help you decide. Read the detailed review below or check out the side-by-side comparison table.

Buffy vs. Cozy Earth vs. Sheets & Giggles
Comparison Table
WHAT ARE THE BEST NON-COTTON SHEETS?Buffy LogoCozy Earth LogoSheets & Giggles Logo
PriceaddBuffy💰💰💰Cozy Earth💰💰💰💰Sheets & Giggles💰💰
Biggest Selling PointaddBuffyEarth Friendly MissionCozy EarthOprah's Favorite ThingsSheets & GigglesBold and Sassy Style
Fabric SourceaddBuffyEucalyptusCozy EarthBambooSheets & GigglesEucalyptus
Thread CountaddBuffy300Cozy EarthNot Disclosed, Company Prefers Focus on ReviewsSheets & Giggles400
HypoallergenicaddBuffyCozy EarthSheets & Giggles
Color ProfileaddBuffyNeutral TonesCozy EarthWhiteSheets & GigglesVibrant Colors
Sustainable FocusaddBuffyCozy EarthSheets & Giggles
ShippingaddBuffyFree Shipping & ReturnsCozy EarthFree Shipping & ReturnsSheets & GigglesFree Shipping To Most US Homes
WebsiteaddBuffyCozy EarthSheets & Giggles

Why Buy Hypoallergenic Sheets?

The apparent reason to buy hypoallergenic sheets is to fight back against allergies, but the reason hypoallergenic sheets are so important might be more profound than you think. Hypoallergenic sheets repel allergens from the surface where you sleep and protect your mattress, box springs, and pillow as well.

It is one thing to make sure your sheets are fresh, but it is an entirely taller task to make sure your bed itself is staying fresh. Mattresses, box springs, and pillows are expensive, so chances are you keep them for a decade or more. Considering how much you have invested in your bed, hypoallergenic sheets are vital for protecting your mattress from dust mites, dead skin, bacteria, and other allergens.

Investing in cotton-alternative, hypoallergenic sheets is a simple solution to help you fight your allergies at night. If that isn’t reason enough, these hypoallergenic properties will help your skin, too. Because they are moisture-wicking and repel bacteria, your skin will stay cleaner.

Non-Cotton Sheets Made From Eucalyptus and Bamboo are Sustainable

These hypoallergenic sheets are softer than cotton sheets, and the production process is often better for the planet. It generally takes less water and energy to produce eucalyptus sheets, as an example. Eucalyptus trees can be grown with 10X less water than it takes to grow cotton, and because trees are less susceptible to pest damage than cotton plants, pesticides aren’t needed either.

Two of the sheets highlighted originate from Eucalyptus trees, and both Buffy and Sheets & Giggles work with sustainable farmers. Buffy’s partner plants four trees for every three trees harvested. Sheets & Giggles plants two trees for every tree harvested and plants one tree for every order received.

That’s a lot of trees, so not only is the world’s tree canopy being replenished, but less water and electricity is being used. Cozy Earth is in on the game too. The bamboo used by Cozy Earth is stringently sourced from USDA certified organic farms, and they utilize reusable packaging. Cotton sheets require more water, electricity, and pesticides than either eucalyptus or bamboo sheets.


Sheets & Giggles vs.Cozy Earth vs. Buffy Review Article - Sustainable Image

Don’t Sweat It: Cotton-Alternative Materials Are Cooler Than Cotton

Buffy, Cozy Earth, and Sheets & Giggles are clearly three of the best options if you are looking to invest in quality, non-cotton sheets. If you are worried about sacrificing comfort to buy these hypoallergenic sheets, worry no more. Sheets originating from eucalyptus and bamboo are naturally softer and cooler than traditional cotton sheets. Say goodbye to the night sweats.

There are plenty of companies out there that sell non-cotton or hypoallergenic sheets as a fringe part of a more extensive line-up, almost like a novelty. Buffy, Cozy Earth, and Sheets & Giggles specialize in eucalyptus/bamboo sheets because they believe eucalyptus and bamboo make the best sheets.

The benefits are clear. Not only are the sheets hypoallergenic, but they are sustainably made and widely considered more comfortable than cotton sheets.

Buffy Sheets Review: Sleep Well And Care For Earth Too

Buffy is so confident you will love their sheets that they offer a free 7-night trial. While the thought of returning sheets does seem a little strange

, it does speak to their confidence in the product. Buffy only completes the transaction based on what you choose to keep. That is a pretty bold policy, but perhaps it is the cool-to-touch and softer-than-cotton features they believe will convince you.

If not these features, perhaps it’s the hypoallergenic or highly breathable nature of the fabric they are counting on to convince you. Regardless, these sheets are like sliding into clouds that are somehow both cozy and cool, and Buffy is convinced you will become a believer too.

Diving Deeper Into Buffy Sheets

An incredible amount of thought and responsibility goes into Buffy sheets. The fabric comes from a regenerative forest, and only natural dyes such as tea, gardenias, and turmeric are used to add color to the sheets. The eucalyptus is sourced from Austria, using 10x less water than producing cotton sheets.

And if you don’t like the sheets? Customers are encouraged to donate products they don’t want in exchange for a refund because returns are an inherently inefficient process increasing CO2 emissions. They put their money where their beliefs are, and we think that is pretty cool.

Perhaps the best thing about Buffy is that when you buy these sheets, you will both indulge in comfort and make a decision responsible to the planet. The eucalyptus fibers are just as durable as cotton, but not only are they softer, but they will get softer over time. Each time you wash your sheets, you will love them more than the last time you slept on them.

It’s a win-win situation, so when you buy new sheets from Buffy, you can go ahead and purchase a new comforter and pillows too.

Buffy vs. Cozy Earth vs. Sheets & Giggles Review Image

More Buffy Customer Reviews

Don’t want to take our word for it? We understand. We carefully curated the most insightful reviews from around the web, so they are all right here at your fingertips. Each brand has its unique qualities that helped them rise to our list of the three best non-cotton, hypoallergenic sheets, and that shines through in the customer reviews. Check them out for yourself:

Review from Dani: I bought the entire set- cloud comforter, sheets, and duvet. Best decision ever made! So fluffy & cozy!! Treat yo self!

Review from Michael: Really enjoying getting into bed every evening after switching to Buffy bedding. I am cool through the night and wake up feeling refreshed and ready to take on the day.

Review from Lisa: Oh my goodness!!! These sheets are amazing. They are so soft and buttery straight from the box but were even softer after the first wash. We have been sleeping so well in these bad boys!

Review from Natalie: I am a hot sleeper, so I ordered the eucalyptus sheets, especially for my summer sleeps. I don’t have any AC, so I inevitably always sweat at night but don’t want to wash my sheets every day. After a week of sleeping with them, I am impressed with how they resist getting sweat stains. This helps me to feel cool, as the sheets below me never feel damp.

Buffy Sheets Review: The Verdict

Our favorite thing about the Buffy brand is that their line-up includes hypoallergenic comforters and pillows, including a comforter option (The Buffy Breeze) that is 100% Eucalyptus sourced. And according to Buffy, their other comforter (The Buffy Cloud) is rated fluffier than a marshmallow 😃. If you are looking for a complete bedroom overhaul, then Buffy might be for you. Who doesn’t want to sleep under clouds fluffier than marshmallows?


SUMMARYthumb_upPROS
thumb_downCONS
  • check Eucalyptus fibers
  • close Moderately expensive
  • check Sustainably Sourced
  • close Muted color choices
  • check Only natural dyes
  • check Soft to touch, softer over time
  • check Hypoallergenic

Buffy vs. Sheets & Giggles vs. Cozy Earth Review Image

Cozy Earth Sheets Review: The Best Bamboo Sheets On The Market

Cozy Earth bamboo sheets twice made the cut for Oprah’s famous list of her Favorite Things, so if you are looking for hypoallergenic bamboo sheets, your search should stop and end with Cozy Earth. While Sheets & Giggles capitalizes on their bold and sassy style, Cozy Earth is in many ways the exact opposite. Cozy Earth products come in white. That’s it. Cozy Earth knows their value is in comfort and durability, so they let the product speak for itself.

How can they be so confident in their product that they don’t even offer multiple colors? The founder of Cozy Earth traveled around the world personally, building each part of the company’s eventual supply chain. Many companies sell “bamboo sheets” that are unrefined bamboo blends, but Cozy Earth invested in developing high-end bamboo products to enhance the features that come naturally from bamboo.


Diving Deeper into Cozy Earth Sheets

Like eucalyptus sheets, bamboo sheets are softer than cotton, but bamboo is particularly effective at regulating body temperature. The high-quality nature of these bamboo sheets also maximizes their hypoallergenic nature. Let’s be clear, these are the most expensive sheets on our list, but the price is reflective of both the research invested in the product and the general quality of the product.

Cozy Earth’s attention to quality details extends throughout its portfolio, meaning they know precisely where the bamboo comes from and how it is processed into the perfect bamboo sheets. No harmful chemicals or pesticides are used. Because so much time was invested into developing the ideal bamboo fabric, the benefits would be wasted if they didn’t extend beyond sheets and bedding.

Cozy Earth has extended their bamboo quality to an entire loungewear line, so whether you are looking for temperature regulating pajamas and komodo robes, or searching for a less humid pullover, Cozy Earth has you covered. Start with sheets, then expand to other bedding, and complete the circle with new loungewear. If it is good enough for Oprah, you won’t regret your purchase.


Cozy Earth vs. Buffy vs. Sheets & Giggles Review Image

More Cozy Earth Customer Reviews

What are other customers saying? Let’s check it out:

Review from Carrie: I know people say this all the time about Cozy Earth, but you do feel like you’re sleeping in a fancy boutique hotel bed when using this bedding! It’s beyond soft and feels supercooling, too, which is a must for us since we live in a 1960s home without air conditioning. My advice is to go the full nine yards and get the sheets AND duvet cover because that combo turned our king bed into a cloud. I couldn’t recommend it more!

Review from Mary: I honestly did not believe that there would be a big difference, or that I would even notice a difference, from other sheets. You definitely will see!!! It’s lovely to sleep on these sheets! It feels luxurious and comfortable at the same time. Treat yourself. You are worth it, & so are these sheets!

Review from Cynde: Amazing! They are so comfortable, and I don’t get as hot when I sleep! I absolutely love them. I will keep using the set I bought, washing and putting back on until I can afford to buy another set. I also purchased the pajamas made out of the same material, and they are so soft and comfortable. Best I’ve ever had for sure!

Review from Melinda: Hands down the softest sheets I have ever slept on, and I buy lots and lots of bedding. These are an absolute Win. I have been sleeping well.

Cozy Earth Sheets Review: The Verdict

Cozy Earth’s Bamboo sheets might be considered a bit of a luxury product, and we understand why. Not only are they sustainably sourced through a custom-designed supply chain, but the Bamboo fibers also have excellent natural properties to help regulate your body temperature. The sheets are hypoallergenic too. Cozy Earth sheets are a little expensive, and you might prefer a little spice beyond white, but if the sheets are good enough for Oprah…


SUMMARYthumb_upPROS
thumb_downCONS
  • check Oprah’s Favorite Things
  • close Expensively priced
  • check Bamboo fibers
  • close Only available in white
  • check Sustainably Sourced
  • check No chemicals used
  • check Naturally regulate body temperature
  • check Hypoallergenic

Cozy Earth vs. Sheets & Giggles vs. Buffy Review Image

Sheets & Giggles Review: Sustainable Meets Sassy

Sheets & Giggles stands out as a bold company in many ways. The name is edgy, the sheets come in vibrant colors (like royal purple and mint green), the website has a few “easter eggs” to be found, and they have a VP of Barketing. No, that wasn’t a typo.

The founder’s dog has an entire page on the website dedicated to him, and they call him the VP of Barketing. If you like to have a little fun in your sheets, you should probably go ahead and buy some Sheets & Giggles right now. Besides, Sheets & Giggles’ eucalyptus sheets are naturally softer, more breathable, and better at moisture-wicking than cotton sheets.


Diving Deeper into Sheets & Giggles

Like Buffy before, Sheets & Giggles does things the right way. The company claims “near-zero” waste and 96% less water used during production than cotton-based counterparts. If that’s not awesome enough, because sheets are the #2-most-requested item at homeless shelters, when you donate your old sheets, Sheets & Giggles will give you 10% off your next purchase. Dang.

Sheets & Giggles’ focus on establishing the best possible sourcing and production processes is mirrored in the brand’s product quality. Sheets & Giggles sheets have 400 thread count, which is the highest published thread count among the brands we reviewed. That is particularly noteworthy, given their sheets are also the most affordable sheets we reviewed.

But why stop at 400 count? Everyone has seen those 800, 900, and 1000+ count sheets on the market. Here is the dirty secret. Above 400 count, there is no discernible difference in the softness of the sheet. On the other hand, the sheets do become noticeably less breathable as the thread count increases.

Based on Sheets & Giggles’ experimentation and research, 400 count is the perfect sweet spot to maximize softness and breathability. More on that to come if you are looking for a better understanding of thread counts.

Sheets & Giggles vs.Cozy Earth vs. Buffy Review Article - Unboxing 2 Image

What’s our favorite detail? It’s hard to pick with the sustainably driven business approach and vibrant colors, but the small details matter. Sheets & Giggles have little tags telling you which corner goes where. You know what a big deal this is for anyone who has ever fought to get the fitted sheet on a king-size bed.

Sheets & Giggles carefully considered every little detail of these sheets, from choosing responsibly managed forests for sourcing to making it easier for you to make the bed. They sell comforters, duvet covers, and throw blankets, too, so once you fall in love with Eucalyptus, you will probably be headed back for more.

On a less serious note, Sheets & Giggles has a no questions asked return policy. If you don’t love your sheets, send them back, and you will get a refund. This seems a little less awkward than the “sleep in our sheets for seven days and send them back if you don’t like them” model. I mean, it’s not like any brand is going to repackage returned sheets to sell to another customer, regardless of whether it has been 7 or 8 days.

Regardless, Sheets & Giggles sheets are the most luxurious-feeling sheets I have ever slept in, so in my mind, you would be crazy to return them.


Sheets & Giggles vs. Buffy vs. Cozy Earth Review Image

More Sheets & Giggles Customer Reviews

What are other customers saying? Let’s check it out:

Review from Reagan: We are obsessed with our sheets! They are a perfect size and so comfortable. We also loved the fast shipping and fun packaging. We will be ordering again!

Review from Chelsea: My husband and I are opposite sleepers. He loves it cold, and I like it warm. These sheets are the best of both worlds. They are incredibly soft, hands down the softest sheets I’ve ever owned. They are cool for him and comfy warm for me. I love the extra deep pockets on the fitted sheet. We recently bought a new mattress (purple), and our old sheets weren’t deep enough, so they kept coming off. These Sheets & Giggles fit perfectly, and no one is fighting over them. Highly recommend!

Review from Lisa: I’ve wanted these sheets for months, and finally, my husband surprised me with them for Mother’s Day! There was an error made (on our end), so I emailed the company about it on a Friday night, assuming they would not get back to me until Monday. But to my surprise, they actually got back to me the next day. After a few emails back and forth, and our issue was resolved. The customer service rep got back to us very quickly. We are so in love with our sheets and can’t wait to buy their blanket in the future.

Sheets & Giggles Sheets Review: The Verdict

Does Sheets & Giggles make fantastic sheets? The answer is, “Sheet, Yeah!” Honestly, it is hard to find much to complain about with their sheets. Their business and product show attention to detail at every level. The Eucalyptus is sustainably sourced, the 400 thread count is the sweet spot of softness and breathability, and their sheets are more affordable than the competition. Not to mention, their brand is just fun.

Our best nights of sleep have come between Sheets & Giggles sheets.


SUMMARYthumb_upPROS
thumb_downCONS
  • check Best value reviewed
  • close Not many. The worst we can say is that they don’t have pillows or other products to complement their awesome bedding.
  • check Eucalyptus fibers
  • check Sustainably Sourced
  • check Discount available if you donate old sheets to a homeless shelter
  • check Clever corners to help you make the bed
  • check Come in both bold and neutral colors
  • check Hypoallergenic

Sheets & Giggles vs.Cozy Earth vs. Buffy Review Image - Try Now

Eucalyptus vs. Bamboo Sheets: Which Sheets Are Better?

Even when compared to cotton, “better” may be in the eye of the beholder. That said, we are particularly fond of Eucalyptus and Bamboo sheets. Heck, Oprah is partial to Bamboo too. And it’s not just a matter of preference. There are some tangible benefits to be both Eucalyptus and Bamboo sheets, including the fact both are more sustainable than cotton. Eucalyptus and Bamboo sheets are also noticeably soft and breathable as a result of their natural fiber properties.

But between Eucalyptus and Bamboo, which is better? Converting bamboo down into fibers which can be woven into sheets, is frequently a chemically driven process. It is potentially harmful to the workers, and the runoff from the process can be environmentally detrimental. As seen in our comparison, Eucalyptus sheets are also a more reasonable price. All considered, we recommend you invest in Eucalyptus sheets.

Sheets & Giggles vs. Cozy Earth vs. Buffy Review Article - Sustainable Sheets Image

Does Thread Count Matter?

Like most anything in life, the answer is: “It depends.” Generally speaking, the higher the thread count your sheets have, the softer they are, and the better they wear with time. Since the thread count refers to the number of vertical and horizontal threads per square inch, sheets with higher thread counts have finer threads that are more tightly woven. Low thread counts might feel coarse if they are woven with thicker yarn.

Some companies artificially play up their thread counts, weaving their sheets with tricks of the trade, but at some point, any increase in the thread count offers a negligible difference to the consumer. And other factors impact your sheets’ softness anyway. Sheets come in different weave patterns and are finished in various ways too.

Indeed, the material matters as well. Even among cotton sheets, certain types of cotton are considered softer than other types. Have you ever heard of Egyptian cotton? Eucalyptus and Bamboo sheets are both known to be supremely soft, which needs to be considered in conjunction with the thread count.

So does thread count matter? Yes. The ideal thread count is probably somewhere between 300 and 500. Sheets in this thread count will be noticeably softer than sheets with lower thread counts; however, if you start to see claims of sheets with 1,000+ thread counts having other-worldly softness, be skeptical.

WinkBed Reviews - Sleep Well

We’ve poured countless hours into researching and sampling the best non-cotton sheets on the market. We are convinced that Buffy, Cozy Earth, and Sheets & Giggles are the best. Each brand stands out in different ways, but we recommend Sheets & Giggles.

Like the other options on our list, they are softer and cooler than cotton counterparts and sustainably made, but Sheets & Giggles unapologetically stands out on styling. Referencing the queen sheets as a benchmark, Sheets & Giggles is about 25% more affordable than Buffy while offering 400 thread count to Buffy’s 300 thread count. Compared to Cozy Earth, Sheets & Giggles is nearly half the price. Sheets & Giggles products are an excellent value.

The excitement will start as soon as you receive your Sheets & Giggles package in the mail. If you’ve checked out their website, you will be unsurprised to know the 100% recyclable cardboard box is a fun purple color. And rather than use plastic packaging, Sheets & Giggles packages their sheets in a luxurious, Eucalyptus bag. Best yet, depending on what you order, your package may include a soft, Sheets & Giggles stylized sleeping mask.

Sheets & Giggles vs.Cozy Earth vs. Buffy Review Article - Unboxing Image

It’s the complete package in more ways than one. What about the sheets themselves? You might be disappointed if you expect fog-like clouds to surround your hand the first time you touch them, but once you get the sheets on the bed, the softness is undeniable. They are the softest, most breathable sheets I have ever slept in, and they often feel cool to the touch when you first slide in.

And like fine wine, they get better with time. We were pleasantly surprised that with the first few washes, the sheets seemed to soften even more. If you are considering purchasing new sheets, purchase

Sheets & Giggles today, and sleep better tomorrow.

Sheets & Giggles vs.Cozy Earth vs. Buffy Review Article Image

Subscribe to Moonlight Reviews

Get the latest posts delivered right to your inbox!